3 Historic New Jersey Homes With Million-Dollar Price Tags

3 Million-Dollar Century Homes in New Jersey with Stunning Architecture
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

New Jersey, with its rich architectural heritage, boasts some of the most remarkable century-old homes in the United States, particularly in towns like Rutherford and Beach Haven. These historic properties are celebrated for their intricate Victorian, Colonial Revival, and Tudor designs, showcasing grand facades, detailed moldings, and elegant stained-glass windows. Expansive interiors feature soaring ceilings, original hardwood floors, and ornate fireplaces, offering a glimpse into a bygone era. Many have been meticulously restored to preserve their architectural integrity, making them highly coveted for their blend of historical charm and modern luxury.

1. 1900 Elegant Victorian Home in Rutherford

1900 Elegant Victorian Home in Rutherford
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

Listed at $3,850,000, this rare investment opportunity in Rutherford, NJ, presents The Loffredo Estate. Spanning three conjoined properties on 0.656 acres, the estate comprises three buildings with 11 multifamily units, five garages, and additional parking. The architectural style reflects classic Victorian design with intricate details and a robust layout. One unit, featuring three bedrooms and a semi-finished basement, is ideal for an owner-operator. Located near public transportation and vibrant downtown Rutherford, this property offers prime rental potential and investment opportunities. The properties must be purchased together.

Where is Rutherford?

Where is Rutherford?
Bing Maps

Rutherford, New Jersey, is located just 12 miles from Manhattan, offering residents easy access to urban amenities while maintaining a small-town charm. Historically known for its role in the railroad industry, Rutherford has grown into a thriving community that blends rich history with modern living. The town’s attractive mix of historical architecture and contemporary homes makes it a prime location for residential housing. Today, Rutherford’s proximity to transportation and vibrant local businesses, along with its family-friendly atmosphere, contributes to its desirability as a sought-after housing area.

Aerial View

Aerial View
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

This aerial view of Rutherford, NJ, highlights the charming, well-maintained neighborhood, showcasing a mix of traditional homes with contemporary updates. The wide streets, surrounded by lush greenery, exude a peaceful suburban atmosphere. The homes, many with unique architectural details, are nestled on large, spacious lots, offering ample outdoor space for residents. This bird’s-eye perspective highlights the community’s blend of classic charm and modern living, making it a highly sought-after location for potential homeowners. The proximity to transportation hubs further enhances the appeal of Rutherford as a desirable housing area.

Living Room

Inviting Spacious Living Room
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

The living room in this home exudes a relaxed and modern vibe with its dark, neutral furniture complemented by vibrant, golden accents. The rich textures of the velvet cushions and woven coffee table provide depth and warmth to the minimalist decor. The layout is open, making the room feel spacious and inviting. Large, floor-to-ceiling windows let in plenty of natural light, and the stylish artwork on the walls adds a pop of visual interest. The overall design creates an ideal space for both entertaining and unwinding.

Sleek Modern Kitchen

Sleek Modern Kitchen
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

This kitchen blends modern minimalism with functional elegance. The gray walls pair perfectly with the clean lines of the white cabinetry, offering a stylish and efficient cooking space. A contemporary light fixture above the dining area adds a playful touch, while the black-and-white checked curtains bring an unexpected burst of charm. The kitchen’s well-lit atmosphere, coupled with high-end appliances and sleek countertops, gives it a sophisticated feel. The layout provides ample counter space and easy access to the dining area, creating a perfect space for both cooking and entertaining.

Stylish Bedroom

Stylish Bedroom
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

This cozy bedroom balances contemporary design with a touch of vintage charm. The muted gray walls set a calm tone, accentuated by the ornate black bed frame. A striking chandelier overhead adds an elegant flair, while the plush bedding in deep shades of black and white offers comfort. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, creating a bright and airy atmosphere. Black and white patterned curtains add depth and interest, creating an ideal space for relaxation or restful sleep.

Bright Modern Bathroom

Bright Modern Bathroom
Jennifer Darby Metzger @ The Agency Rutherford

This sleek bathroom boasts an elegant, modern design with a touch of sophistication. The white marble tiles on the walls add a clean, luxurious look, while the contemporary gray vanity provides both style and functionality. A minimalistic mirror enhances the clean lines, reflecting the soft light and brightening the space. The simple yet effective layout, combined with fresh greenery in the space, creates an atmosphere of tranquility, making it a perfect place for relaxation. The design focuses on maximizing space while maintaining a chic, modern aesthetic.

Source: The Agency Rutherford via Zillow

2. 1882 Beautiful Victorian Home in Beach Haven

1880 Beautiful Victorian Home in Beach Haven
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

Listed at $4,400,000, this 1800s Victorian home offers 8 bedrooms and 6 baths within 3,391 sqft of living space. The architecture is a striking example of the classic Victorian style, complete with intricate woodwork, a sprawling wraparound porch, and steep gabled roofs. Large windows flood the rooms with natural light, highlighting the beautiful hardwood floors and historic features. Modern amenities blend seamlessly with the traditional design, providing a luxurious yet nostalgic atmosphere. This historic gem combines the elegance of the past with today’s comforts.

Where is Beach Haven?

Where is Beach Haven?
Bing Maps

Beach Haven, located on Long Beach Island in New Jersey, is a historic coastal town known for its Victorian architecture and scenic beaches. It was originally established in the mid-1800s and rapidly became a popular resort destination, earning the nickname “Queen City of the Jersey Shore.” Today, Beach Haven still holds its historical charm while embracing modern luxury. The town’s prime location on the Atlantic Ocean, paired with its thriving real estate market, makes it a sought-after place for both seasonal and year-round residents.

Stylish Living Room

Stylish Living Room
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

The living room exudes style and comfort, with a unique brick feature wall providing a rustic yet elegant focal point. The contemporary furniture in soft tones complements the room’s classic hardwood floors and abundant natural light from multiple windows. The space is open and airy, with a cozy sitting area designed for both relaxation and socializing. It offers a perfect blend of modern comfort and historical charm, creating a balanced and inviting space for family and guests.

Kitchen Space

Sophisticated Kitchen Space
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

A beautiful blend of modern design and classic elements, this spacious kitchen is a culinary enthusiast’s dream. The rich blue cabinetry contrasts beautifully with the white countertops and tile backsplash, while the hardwood floors add warmth to the space. High-end stainless-steel appliances, including a professional-grade oven, enhance the kitchen’s appeal. The large windows allow abundant natural light, and the open layout connects seamlessly to the dining and living areas, making it perfect for entertaining guests or enjoying family meals.

Dining Area

Elegant Dining Area
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

In this sophisticated dining area, timeless design meets practicality. The sturdy black chairs and the round marble table create a formal yet welcoming space. Large bay windows offer plenty of natural light, showcasing the beautiful exterior view. The room’s traditional hardwood floors enhance the dining experience, giving the space warmth and charm. This area blends the classic aesthetic of Victorian architecture with the clean lines and modern functionality necessary for today’s lifestyle, making it perfect for family gatherings and formal dinners.

Cozy Coastal Bedroom

Cozy Coastal Bedroom
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

This bedroom exudes coastal charm with its light and airy design, perfect for relaxing by the beach. The soft white and neutral tones, combined with the rustic wooden floors, create a peaceful and inviting space. A cozy quilted bedspread, along with sea-inspired accents like hats and greenery, add a beachy touch. The large bay windows invite plenty of natural light, offering beautiful views of the outdoors while keeping the space fresh and breezy. A perfect space to unwind after a day by the ocean.

Bathroom Oasis

Charming Bathroom Oasis
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

This bathroom combines clean lines and luxurious materials, creating a tranquil space to relax and unwind. The black vanity provides a striking contrast to the soft blue walls, while the white marble tilework adds a classic touch. The elegant fixtures, including a vintage-style sink and bathtub, offer a blend of traditional and modern design elements. A glass shower enclosure allows for easy access and a sleek appearance. This bathroom is a perfect example of a thoughtfully designed space that balances beauty with function.

Laundry Space

Laundry Space
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

This cozy laundry area is both functional and charming, featuring a classic blue hue for a serene ambiance. The space is equipped with modern appliances, including a washer and dryer, tucked neatly under slanted ceilings that maximize the room’s size. The large window invites natural light, creating an airy, bright space for daily chores. The traditional wood floors blend seamlessly with the modern touches, offering a perfect example of how this home beautifully combines contemporary comfort with historical appeal.

Backyard Pool

Stunning Backyard Pool
Barb Cona @ Coastal Living Real Estate Group

This stunning backyard pool area offers the perfect setting for relaxation and entertainment. The sleek, modern pool is surrounded by spacious stone pavers and complemented by comfortable lounge chairs, ideal for soaking up the sun. A cozy outdoor dining area under a large umbrella provides the perfect spot for meals or drinks by the poolside. The fenced-in yard, lined with lush greenery, ensures privacy and tranquility. Whether hosting a summer gathering or enjoying quiet moments, this outdoor space blends style and comfort for ultimate enjoyment.

Source: Coastal Living Real Estate Group via Zillow

3. 1882 Timeless Victorian Beauty in Beach Haven

1882 Timeless Victorian Beauty in Beach Haven
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

Listed at $3,699,999, this magnificent Victorian home in Beach Haven, NJ, offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of history. Built in 1882, the home features classic Victorian architectural elements with intricate woodwork, grand columns, and a wraparound porch. Spanning 3,541 sq. ft., the residence offers 6 bedrooms, 6 baths, and ample living space with stunning period details and craftsmanship. The blend of historical charm and modern amenities makes this property a perfect home for those seeking a luxurious and timeless residence in a prime beach location.

Where is Beach Haven?

Where is Beach Haven?
Bing Maps

Located on Long Beach Island, Beach Haven, NJ, is a charming coastal town known for its rich history and vibrant community. The area has been a popular seaside destination for vacationers since the late 19th century, with its Victorian-era homes adding to the town’s historical charm. Today, Beach Haven continues to attract homebuyers seeking the perfect blend of coastal living and small-town charm. Its proximity to beaches, restaurants, and entertainment makes it a highly desirable area for residential housing, offering a laid-back yet active lifestyle.

Living Room

Art-Inspired Living Room
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

This cozy coastal living room captures the essence of relaxed beach living. The soft beige and white tones create a light and airy atmosphere, while the nautical-themed accents, such as starfish pillows and beach-inspired art, infuse the space with charm. The large windows let in plenty of natural light, making the room feel open and welcoming. Comfortable seating areas and a rustic wood coffee table bring a touch of warmth to the room, while the ceiling fan adds a functional and stylish element to this inviting space.

Kitchen Retreat

Gourmet Kitchen Retreat
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

The heart of this home lies in the gourmet kitchen, where functionality meets coastal charm. The bright blue cabinetry contrasts beautifully with the warm wood floors, and the intricate white crown molding adds a touch of elegance. The large kitchen island provides ample space for meal prep and casual dining, while the high-end appliances ensure that cooking and entertaining are a breeze. Nautical-themed décor and the unique ceiling fan complete the coastal theme, making this kitchen not only a functional space but also a beautiful one.

Serenity Bedroom

Seaside Serenity Bedroom
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

This serene bedroom design brings a beachy elegance to life with soft coastal colors and nautical touches. The light blue walls create a calming atmosphere, while the white trim and molding enhance the room’s airy feel. The bed features soft, ocean-inspired patterns, complemented by matching pillows, making it the perfect retreat after a day at the beach. The large windows allow natural light to flood the room, and the ceiling fan adds a touch of breezy comfort. The mix of warm wood floors and inviting textiles creates a relaxed, coastal vibe.

Vintage-Inspired Bathroom

Vintage-Inspired Bathroom
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

This elegant bathroom combines modern functionality with vintage charm. The light blue walls paired with neutral tiles create a fresh, clean look. The intricate wooden mirror frame and elegant faucet fixtures add sophistication, while the glass shower enclosure gives the space a sleek, contemporary feel. Natural light filters in through the window, creating a bright, airy ambiance. The wooden storage shelf offers a natural touch, completing the spa-like atmosphere. This bathroom is a perfect balance of comfort, style, and coastal elegance.

Outdoor Living

Tranquil Outdoor Living
Alan Simonides @ Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom

The outdoor living space of this home is a perfect blend of relaxation and style. The spacious deck area is equipped with comfortable lounge chairs, offering the perfect spot to soak up the sun. Surrounded by lush greenery and a well-maintained white fence, the space feels private and serene. The mix of natural wood and vibrant plants adds warmth and color to the environment. Whether for dining, lounging, or entertaining, this outdoor area provides an ideal place to unwind and enjoy the fresh coastal air.

Source: Weichert Realtors – Ship Bottom via Zillow