Presented in Montauk, The Stone House is a historic oceanfront estate originally built in 1912 and rebuilt in 1991 by Tony Ingrao to preserve its century-old charm while adding modern luxuries. The home features exquisite stonework, custom copper windows, and hand-carved wood exteriors, set on 3.2 acres with 178.7 feet of ocean frontage. This architectural gem offers 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and stunning views of Montauk Lighthouse and Block Island. Additional amenities include a saltwater pool, artist’s studio, and pool house. Priced at $18 million, this rare estate is renowned for its exclusivity and storied past, once occupied by iconic cultural figures.
Coastal Estate Aerial
Sprawling stone mansion perched on a cliffside, overlooking a vibrant blue ocean that stretches to the horizon. The estate is surrounded by lush, dense greenery extending inland, adding privacy and natural beauty. The sloping coastline features rugged cliffs with rocky shorelines below, contrasting with the calm waters. The home has steep, gabled roofs, multiple stone chimneys, and ivy accentuating its historic architecture. A manicured lawn wraps the property, bordered by hedges. In the distance, a white lighthouse stands atop the peninsula, enhancing the picturesque maritime ambiance. The setting evokes timeless elegance and tranquility along the coastline.
Coastal Estate Overview
An expansive coastal property surrounded by lush greenery and mature trees stretches toward a serene ocean horizon. The estate is bordered by a subtle white line defining its spacious grounds. Several large homes with traditional architecture feature steep roofs, chimneys, and stone facades nestled within the landscape. The open grassy areas contrast with the dense grouping of foliage, creating a harmonious blend of cultivated and wild nature. The ocean backdrop lends a peaceful atmosphere, emphasizing the estate’s exclusivity and tranquil setting. Pathways and driveways wind through the property, connecting the impressive residences to the coastal perimeter.
Coastal Estate Grounds
Set on a lush, green coastal hilltop, the landscape features two distinct homes surrounded by dense shrubbery, mature trees, and manicured hedges. The larger, historic stone house with steeply pitched gabled roofs and multiple chimneys evokes timeless charm, positioned prominently near the ocean with unobstructed blue water views. In the foreground, a smaller, more rustic wooden structure with a stone foundation is nestled among natural greenery, showcasing simple architectural lines and woodland colors. The driveways and cleared paths enhance accessibility while maintaining the estate’s natural, serene aesthetic against the vast seaside backdrop.
Coastal Cliffside Estate
A historic stone mansion positioned atop a rugged coastal cliff, bathed in the warm glow of late afternoon sunlight. The house showcases classic American architectural elements with steeply pitched roofs, multiple chimneys, and dormer windows offering expansive views. The cliff is fortified with stone and wooden stairs descending towards a rocky shoreline and gentle waves of the ocean. Green shrubbery and tall grasses envelope the terrain, blending nature’s raw beauty with the stately structure. The serene blue sky and calm water create a perfect harmony of coastal tranquility and historic charm.
Oceanfront Balcony
A weathered wooden balcony lined with turned balusters overlooks a sweeping coastal view. The deck holds a pair of aged wooden chairs positioned for enjoying the panoramic ocean and rugged shoreline. Adjacent to the railing, the home features a stone wall with a distinctive round window framed by rustic wood trim, adding a historic charm. The sloped roof above is clad in wooden shingles, blending naturally with the natural surroundings. Below, a lush green lawn meets a wooden fence, emphasizing the connection between the home and the dramatic cliffside landscape under a clear blue sky.
Oceanfront Balcony View
Wooden balcony railing with classic balusters overlooks a serene ocean vista under a clear blue sky. Two rustic wooden lounge chairs invite relaxation while facing the vast, calm sea. Below, a patch of lush green grass contrasts with the deep blue water, merging nature’s elements harmoniously. The weathered texture of the wooden elements gives a timeless, coastal charm, highlighting the peaceful and breezy ambiance of this outdoor space. This setting perfectly captures tranquility and connection with nature, ideal for enjoying quiet mornings or contemplative sunsets over the water.
Backyard Pool Area
A natural stone-bordered swimming pool is nestled within a spacious, lush green lawn surrounded by mature trees, creating a private and serene outdoor retreat. Adjacent to the pool sits a charming rustic cottage with weathered wooden shingles, a small cupola on the roof, and green-framed French doors, inviting fresh air and light inside. Patio furniture, including sun loungers and a small dining table with chairs, is arranged on a simple paved area, encouraging relaxation and outdoor dining. The entire space is fenced with a black mesh fence, blending subtly with the natural surroundings for safety without disrupting the open landscape feel.
Guest Cottage and Pool
A quaint guest cottage with rustic wood shingles and a steeply pitched roof stands at the center of a lush, leafy backyard. The small structure includes a covered entryway supported by beams and has quaint windows that let in ample light. Surrounding the cottage is a natural stone patio with comfortable outdoor seating including lounge chairs and a small round table, perfect for relaxing or socializing by the pool. The pool has a freeform, asymmetrical shape with steps leading into the water, bordered by flagstone and enclosed by a subtle safety fence, blending harmoniously with the verdant garden and mature trees that create a private, tranquil retreat.
Exterior Side View
Wood-shingled siding covers the two-story structure, exhibiting a weathered, rustic charm. The stone foundation anchors the building, adding sturdy, historic character. A small porch with railings and stone steps leads to a set of double French doors painted in muted teal. Above the doors, transom windows allow additional light inside. The roof has multiple gables with wooden shingles, and upper-level windows are grouped under a dormer. Lush greenery and wild landscaping surround the home, creating a serene, natural setting. The overall atmosphere is tranquil and connected to the surrounding countryside, emphasizing simplicity and durability.
Oceanfront Deck
A spacious wooden deck overlooks a vast, calm ocean, bordered by natural greenery and rugged cliffs. The deck’s weathered wood planks and simple railing exude rustic charm, perfectly blending with the natural surroundings. Two classic Adirondack chairs invite relaxation while soaking in the tranquil water views and open sky. The sunlight casts soft shadows across the deck, highlighting its textured surface and the lush shrubbery on one side. This serene outdoor space offers an unobstructed panorama of the horizon, ideal for peaceful contemplation and enjoying coastal breezes.
Oceanfront Patio Area
A stone exterior wall lines the right side, supporting a covered archway leading to an entryway. A patio area with a wooden dining table and matching chairs sits on a square flagstone base, ideal for outdoor meals while enjoying ocean views. The well-maintained green lawn extends toward a rustic wooden fence that runs parallel to the cliff’s edge. Snow-capped blue ocean waters meet a clear, bright sky at the horizon, enhancing the serene coastal ambiance. The shingle roof and stonework lend a timeless, old-world charm to this seaside setting.
Historic Stone Cottage Exterior
An expansive, lush green lawn stretches out in front of a charming historic stone cottage. The façade is constructed from irregular, rustic stones, giving the home a timeless and sturdy appearance. The roof is wooden and steeply pitched, with several dormer windows and round windows adding architectural interest and natural light inside. Ivy climbs near the central doorway, softening the stone exterior with greenery. Two prominent stone chimneys rise on either side of the cottage, emphasizing its traditional, cozy character. In the background, a clear blue sky meets the horizon, suggesting a serene, open location by the coast.
Historic Stone Home Exterior
A sprawling stone house with a steeply pitched shingled roof, featuring multiple gables and dormer windows, set against a backdrop of dense greenery. Two prominent stone chimneys add to the historic charm, while a wooden balcony runs along the upper floor, aligning with the rustic stone facade. Large windows on the ground floor invite natural light. The house sits on a well-maintained lawn bordered by trimmed hedges. A set of stairs leads down from the yard to a wooden deck with seating overlooking a naturally overgrown, gently sloping embankment. The setting gives a serene, timeless countryside vibe.
Patio Entrance with Ocean View
The setting is an open doorway framed with weathered wooden doors featuring recessed panels and a rounded top arch. Stone walls with natural rugged texture flank the entrance, evoking rustic charm. Beyond the threshold, a stone patio with visible moss and natural wear holds a large wooden table surrounded by matching chairs. The outdoor furniture exhibits a simple, sturdy design with a weathered finish harmonizing with its surroundings. Beyond the patio, lush green grass and a rustic wooden fence edge the cliffside, giving way to a striking unobstructed panoramic ocean view under a clear blue sky, emphasizing a serene coastal ambiance.
Rustic Kitchen Interior
The kitchen is characterized by exposed, heavy wooden ceiling beams and a stone wall backdrop that enhance its rustic charm. A large, weathered wooden table dominates the center, complementing the stone flooring. The cabinetry is painted a deep teal green with a distressed finish, adding vintage character. Stainless steel appliances, including a Viking refrigerator and oversized stove with a modern hood, mix old and new styles. A black wrought-iron chandelier with candle-style bulbs hangs above the table, contributing to the historic, artisanal ambiance. Arched, double wooden doors with natural texture open into the space, reinforcing the classic, cottage-inspired aesthetic.
Rustic Dining Room
Exposed heavy wooden beams punctuate the ceiling, complementing the large dark wood dining table and matching chairs with striped upholstery. A richly patterned oriental rug covers the stone floor, adding warmth and color. The walls are painted with soft, muted greens and intricate botanical motifs, creating an organic, historic ambiance. An arched, weathered wooden door and multiple windows offer natural light and views of the outside. A large, ornately carved cabinet with black accents stands against one wall, accompanied by a small side table stacked with books. Iron candle chandeliers hang overhead, contributing to the old-world charm.
Rustic Attic Bedroom
The bedroom is situated in an attic space characterized by slanted, weathered wooden walls with exposed thick beams that emphasize the historic, rustic charm. A vintage four-poster bed with a tall upholstered headboard anchors the room, paired with a distressed floral chest at the foot. The ceiling features a decorative fan with wooden blades, complementing the room’s natural wood tones. Two small windows flank the bed, allowing natural light, while patterned rugs define distinct areas on the wooden floor. A wooden desk and antique-style lamp add functional charm, blending cozy rustic aesthetic with historic American craftsmanship.
Balcony View
A rustic, clamorous green interior with detailed wood paneling and exposed beams directs attention towards a charming balcony. The wooden door, slightly ajar, reveals a serene seaside view with two classic wooden rocking chairs facing the horizon. Natural light floods in through the large window, accentuating the earthy tones of the room. A tall potted plant and a large freestanding mirror soften the ruggedness, adding warmth and texture. The atmosphere balances cozy cottage aesthetics with openness, creating an inviting transition from an intimate interior to a tranquil outdoor retreat overlooking the ocean.
Listing Agent: Kyle Rosko – Real Estate Sales Person of Douglas Elliman Real Estate via Zillow