A debate over public spending in downtown Rochester escalated this week as the City Council overrode a veto from Mayor Kim Norton. At issue is a $245,000 grant for apartment renovations in a historic building, which Norton argued misuses state funds. The council voted 6-1 to push the project forward, highlighting ongoing tensions over how Destination Medical Center (DMC) dollars should be spent.
Council, Mayor at Odds
The Rochester City Council voted Monday to override Mayor Kim Norton’s veto of a $245,000 grant meant for converting a historic downtown building’s upper floor into apartments. Only Council Member Dan Doering opposed the override, marking a clear divide between the mayor’s office and council priorities.
Mayor Criticizes Apartment Funding
Mayor Norton voiced strong opposition to using DMC infrastructure investment money for the renovation at 324 Broadway Ave. S., owned by Shawn and Michelle Fagan. “As a person who carried this bill, that was not what we said was going to happen,” Norton said. “It really hurts for me to see this happen.”
A Historic Funding Debate
The grant comes from the Destination Medical Center initiative, a $585 million public-private partnership launched in 2013 to boost Rochester’s downtown development. Norton, a former state representative, helped create the DMC with then-GOP Sen. Dave Senjem, intending it for infrastructure projects benefiting the public broadly, not individual property owners.
Council Backs Private Renovations
Despite Norton’s objections, council members sided with proponents who argued that preserving downtown’s historic buildings requires financial incentives. The project would convert a long-vacant second story into apartment space, contributing to the area’s revitalization.
Tension Over Preservation Funding
The decision reignited a long-running debate over how to financially support aging properties downtown. Last year, the city established a historic downtown commercial district and revolving loan program for restoration, but property owners argued that grants, rather than loans, were necessary due to high maintenance costs.
Destination Medical Center’s Goal
The DMC program is funded through city, county, and state dollars aimed at positioning Rochester as a world-class medical destination. The initiative pays for infrastructure upgrades meant to spur new economic activity and investment, though interpretations of eligible projects have become increasingly divisive.
More Debates Likely Ahead
This latest dispute signals continued friction over the DMC’s scope and spending rules. As downtown property owners seek financial support and the city balances public interest with private development, more policy clashes appear inevitable in Rochester’s future.