As California Governor Gavin Newsom emerges as a frontrunner for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination, his rising popularity has sparked both support and criticism. While his ability to attract younger voters and navigate media narratives has made him a formidable candidate, questions about his record on issues like homelessness and his alliances with controversial figures are fueling skepticism about his long-term suitability for the presidency.
Newsom Leads in Early Polling for 2028
In a recent Emerson College Polling survey, Newsom led the pack with 25% support, marking a 13-point surge from June. Former Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg followed with 16%, and Vice President Kamala Harris trailed at 11%. Newsom’s rise, particularly among younger voters who favor him 45% to 28%, has earned him praise for his political maneuvering, especially in fighting Republican gerrymandering efforts and utilizing his social media presence effectively.
Trump Criticizes Newsom’s Leadership
As Newsom’s profile grows, President Donald Trump has been quick to criticize the California governor. Trump recently called Newsom “incompetent” and blamed him for mismanaging the state’s water policies, which he claimed contributed to destructive wildfires. In typical Trump fashion, he made disparaging comments about Newsom’s leadership, which Newsom swiftly responded to on social media, calling out Trump’s past military deployment tactics.
Media Narratives and the White Male Advantage
Despite the praise Newsom receives for his political skill, there’s a growing concern that media narratives may be pushing him to the forefront as the only viable candidate in a crowded Democratic field. The notion that a “white man” is the only one who can win in 2028 has begun to gain traction, though some argue that such thinking undermines diversity and perpetuates established political dynamics.
While Newsom has proven adept at managing public perception, some critics point out his failures in addressing homelessness in California, a crisis that has only worsened under his leadership. His role in the Supreme Court decision allowing cities to criminalize homelessness has drawn significant backlash, especially from progressives who feel Newsom has prioritized political optics over addressing the root causes of poverty.
Newsom’s Critics on Homelessness and Social Issues
As a Californian, I am not as charmed by Newsom’s political moves as others might be. While his social media strategies and redistricting efforts have been effective, they have come at the expense of vulnerable populations. Newsom’s failure to address the state’s homeless crisis, despite having ample power to do so, has been one of his most significant shortcomings. Critics argue that his actions, such as enabling policies that criminalize homelessness, reflect a broader indifference toward poverty and inequality.
Newsom’s Image as a Political “Troll”
In the current political climate, Newsom has often been seen as a foil to Trump, mocking the president’s more extreme stances and positioning himself as a viable alternative. However, his critics contend that Newsom is a “smarmy” political figure who is more interested in boosting his own career than actually helping the most vulnerable. His recent comments on LGBTQ+ issues and alliances with controversial figures have only intensified concerns about his progressive credentials.
A Potential Betrayal of Progressive Values
Supporters of Newsom’s progressive agenda may find themselves conflicted as his background and past actions come under scrutiny. While he has positioned himself as a fighter for progressive causes, many argue that his approach to issues like homelessness, police brutality, and inequality fails to live up to the ideals of true social justice. His willingness to play to the center-right and disregard the most vulnerable in favor of political expediency could ultimately undermine his appeal to a broad, progressive base.
Conclusion: Is Newsom the Right Candidate for 2028?
As we look toward the 2028 election cycle, Newsom’s political ascent is a reminder that media narratives and political strategies often prioritize personality over substance. While his social media savvy and ability to rally support among younger voters make him an appealing candidate for some, his record on homelessness and other critical social issues calls into question whether he is the right person to lead the country. His ability to “troll” Trump may be satisfying in the short term, but a closer examination of his track record reveals a far more complicated and less progressive figure than many might want to believe.